Thursday, October 1, 2009
In American politics, there is no ‘we’ today
I was in Israel interviewing Prime Minister Mr Yitzhak Rabin just before he was assassinated in 1995. We had a beer in his office. He needed one. I remember the ugly mood in Israel then — a mood in which extreme Right-wing settlers and politicians were doing all they could to delegitimise Rabin, who was committed to trading land for peace as part of the Oslo accords. They questioned his authority. They accused him of treason. They created pictures depicting him as a Nazi SS officer, and they shouted death threats at rallies. His political opponents winked at it all.
And in so doing they created a poisonous political environment that was interpreted by one Right-wing Jewish settler as a licence to kill Rabin — he must have heard, “God will be on your side” — and so he did.
Others have already remarked on this analogy, but I want to add my voice because the parallels to Israel then and America today turn my stomach: I have no problem with any of the substantive criticism of President Barack Obama from the Right or Left. But something very dangerous is happening. Criticism from the far Right has begun tipping over into delegitimation and creating the same kind of climate here that existed in Israel on the eve of the Rabin assassination.
What kind of madness is it that someone would create a poll on Facebook asking respondents, “Should Obama be killed?” The choices were: “No, Maybe, Yes, and Yes, if he cuts my healthcare”. The Secret Service is now investigating. I hope they put the jerk in jail and throw away the key because this is exactly what was being done to Rabin.
Even if you are not worried that someone might draw from these vitriolic attacks a licence to try to hurt the US President, you have to be worried about what is happening to American politics more broadly.
Our leaders, even the President, can no longer utter the word “we” with a straight face. There is no more “we” in American politics at a time when “we” have these huge problems — the deficit, the recession, healthcare, climate change and wars in Iraq and Afghanistan — that “we” can only manage, let alone fix, if there is a collective “we” at work.
Sometimes I wonder whether George H.W. Bush, President “41”, will be remembered as our last “legitimate” President. The Right impeached Bill Clinton and hounded him from day one with the bogus Whitewater “scandal”. George W. Bush was elected under a cloud because of the Florida voting mess, and his critics on the Left never let him forget it.
And Mr Obama is now having his legitimacy attacked by a concerted campaign from the Right fringe. They are using everything from smears that he is a closet “socialist” to calling him a “liar” in the middle of a joint session of Congress to fabricating doubts about his birth in America and whether he is even a citizen. And these attacks are not just coming from the fringe. Now they come from Lou Dobbs on CNN and from members of the House of Representatives.
Again, hack away at the man’s policies and even his character all you want. I know politics is a tough business. But if we destroy the legitimacy of another President to lead or to pull the country together for what most Americans want most right now — nation-building at home — we are in serious trouble. We can’t go 24 years without a legitimate President — not without being swamped by the problems that we will end up postponing because we can’t address them rationally.
The American political system was, as the saying goes, “designed by geniuses so it could be run by idiots”. But a cocktail of political and technological trends have converged in the last decade that are making it possible for the idiots of all political stripes to overwhelm and paralyse the genius of our system.
Those factors are: the wild excess of money in politics; the gerrymandering of political districts, making them permanently Republican or Democratic and erasing the political middle; a 24/7 cable news cycle that makes all politics a daily battle of tactics that overwhelm strategic thinking; and a blogosphere that at its best enriches our debates, adding new checks on the establishment, and at its worst coarsens our debates to a whole new level, giving a new power to anonymous slanderers to send lies around the world. Finally, on top of it all, we now have a permanent presidential campaign that encourages all partisanship, all the time among our leading politicians.
I would argue that together these changes add up to a difference of degree that is a difference in kind — a different kind of American political scene that makes me wonder whether we can seriously discuss serious issues any longer and make decisions on the basis of the national interest.
We can’t change this overnight, but what we can change, and must change, is people crossing the line between criticising the President and tacitly encouraging the unthinkable and the unforgivable.
Monday, September 21, 2009
Worldwide swine flu toll over 2,100: WHO
All the six WHO regions have reported deaths from the pandemic, with the Americas reporting the largest death number of 1,876, the UN agency said in a latest update of the situation.
In southeast Asia, 139 deaths were recorded, followed by Europe with at least 85 deaths. Deaths in the West Pacific, Africa and East Mediterranean stand at 64, 11 and 10 respectively.
The total number of lab confirmed swine flu cases reported worldwide is 2,09,438, but this actually understates the real number of cases as countries are no longer required to test and report individual cases, the WHO said.
The WHO warned that the H1N1 pandemic virus "has rapidly established itself and is now the dominant influenza strain in most parts of the world."
"The pandemic will persist in the coming months as the virus continues to move through susceptible populations," it said in a statement.
It advised countries in the northern hemisphere to prepare for a second wave of pandemic spread.
"Countries with tropical climates, where the pandemic virus arrived later than elsewhere, also need to prepare for an increasing number of cases," it added.
According to WHO experts, there are currently no signs that the H1N1 virus has mutated to a more virulent or lethal form
ndia is in need of robust National Awards
Just about every country presents national awards for films. The difference with India is that they are all homogenous countries, speaking in a single tongue, not only in terms of the actual language spoken but the film language used. From China to Spain, they do not go through the excruciating exercise of pitting an Aamir Khan film in Hindi against a Priyadarshan film in Tamil. How do you appraise the two? What is the yardstick you use? How do you compare the film language used in Shivajee Chandrabhushan’s Frozen with the Aditya Chopra-produced Chak De! India?
Apparently, to distinguish “artistic” cinema from the “popular” one, our National Awards authorities have adopted a system of having numerous categories: “Wholesome Entertainment”, “Best Film on National Integration”, “Best Film on Family Welfare”, etc. Here, it is the content that matters — with quality of filmmaking, of course, taken into consideration. But the film language varies so dramatically that judging is an onerous task, particularly in view of the huge number of films entered for the awards. And then, if there is an Adoor Gopalakrishnan or a Shyam Benegal or a Mani Ratnam film in competition, few would have the temerity to ignore it while deciding upon the prizes. Yet, no one can produce a masterpiece each time, and it has to be recognised that once in a blue moon, a young newcomer can come up with something so powerful, so original that he or she deserves to prevail over the well-established names. It has happened in big festivals like Cannes, Berlin and Venice, but is unheard of in our own national competition. Perhaps a rule should be introduced that the Best Film and Best Director can be won by a single individual no more than three times!
Parallel to the National Awards are the state film awards in each language. How do National Awards for best “regional language” films compare with the awards presented in each state? It would be interesting to study the differences in perception between the state awards and the National Awards. It’s somewhat like a comparison between national and international awards. A striking recent example is the Filipino film Engkwentro which got a Jury Special Mention at the recent Cinemalaya film festival in Manila and went on to garner two awards at the Venice film festival. The jury at Cinemalaya was composed of three Filipinos and two foreigners, while the two juries in Venice which gave Engkwentro a major award each — the Luigi De Laurentis prize for Best First Film and the Horizons award for Best Film — had no Filipino member. Does that tell us something about the way we look at our own films? In India that would apply to the regional awards and members of the National Awards jury who come from all parts of the country. There is a fundamental question here on the understanding of cultures.
Once I was dismissive of a Bengali film proposed for inclusion in a film festival of which I was the Director. “No”, I said categorically. “Too sentimental, too wishy-washy — even if sensitively shot”. To which the very bright, cinema-literate young Bengali working with me responded, “But Aruna di, most Bengalis are like that”. It got me thinking about the absolute necessity to understand the cultural diversity in at least our own country and to take that into consideration when judging the quality of a film. It is not necessary that each film conform to an international — i.e. European — definition of cinema. To really judge a film, one needs to understand the language, culture, history, politics and the very ethos of the country where it comes from and, in India, the region where it is made. And, in addition, bring to this judging an understanding of cinema as a form. No mean task. A well-nigh impossible one, in fact.
The National Awards this time have been mercifully free of controversy — no doubt a great relief to the organisers in view of the court case they had to face and which is the reason the awards have been delayed in the past two years. One of the jury members went to court saying she did not agree with the prizes agreed upon. That is inadmissible and should not, in fact, have been entertained as a valid complaint. As a member of the jury, one is committed to go with the majority decision, however much one may disagree with it as an individual. What does, however, need to be examined by the organisers are the recommendations of the juries; examined, and the decision for or against, made known before the next round of awards. The next round of awards is, imminent. Because of the delay in the 2007 awards, which have only just been announced to be followed soon by the presentation ceremony, the 2008 awards will also be judged before the end of this financial year. Presented as it is by the President of India, a National Award has an aura and prestige that all film people across the board yearn for. The ceremony itself remains a rather staid affair. Without making it a glittering, glamour-filled occasion, perhaps, something could be done to invest it with the pomp and majesty of a state event.
