Thursday, October 8, 2009
US debates govt’s role, lobbyists smile
Mr Bentham knows everything. He went to Stanford, then to the Kennedy School before getting a business degree. He’s got multivariate regressions coming out of his ears, and he sprinkles CBO reports on his corn flakes for added fibre.
Mr Hume is very smart, too, but he doesn’t seem to make much use of his intelligence. He worked on Wall Street for a little while, but he never could accurately predict how the market was going to move tomorrow or the day after that.
Mr Bentham is a great lunch partner. If you ask him to recommend a bottle of wine, he’ll reel off the six best vintages on the wine list, in ranked preference. Mr Hume can’t even tell you which entree to order because he doesn’t know what you like.
If you put Mr Bentham in charge of the government, he’d proceed with confidence. If you told him to solve a complicated issue like the global-warming problem, he’d gather the smartest people in the country and he’d figure out how to expand wind, biomass, solar and geothermal sources to reduce CO2 emissions. He’d require utilities to contribute $1 billion a year to a Carbon Storage Research Consortium. He’d draw up regulations determining how much power plants would be allowed to pollute.
He’d know about battery efficiency and building retrofit programmes, and he’d give you a long string of dazzling proposals. So then you’d ask him to solve the healthcare mess.
He’d say we have to cover the uninsured without bankrupting the country. He’d design a set of insurance policy regulations to make sure everybody gets uniform care. He’d get out his magnifying glass and help pay for expanded coverage by identifying waste in Medicare.
Then, he’d say, we’ve got to change the way government reimburses providers. He’d set up a $1 billion-a-year Innovation Centre within the department of health and human services. He’d organise a superempowered Medicare commission to rewrite regulations and hold down costs. He’d set up comparative effectiveness research centres with teams of experts who would determine what treatments work best. He’d encourage doctors to merge their practices into efficient teams because he’d seen successful pilot programmes along that line.
Mr Hume, I’m afraid, wouldn’t be so impressive. If you asked him to take on global warming, he’d pile up reports on the problem. But if you walked into his office after a few days, you’d find papers strewn in great piles on the floor and him at his desk with his head in his hands.
“I don’t know the best way to generate clean energy”, he’d whine, “and I don’t know how technology will advance in the next 20 years. Why don’t we just raise the price on carbon and let everybody else figure out how to innovate our way toward a solution? Or at worst, why don’t we just set up a simple cap-and-trade system — with no special-interest favourites — and let entrepreneurs figure out how to bring down emissions?” On healthcare, he’d be much the same. He’d spend a few days reading reports. Then one day you’d find him in the foetal position, weeping. He’d confess that he doesn’t know enough to reorganise a fifth of the economy. He can’t figure out which healthcare delivery system is the most efficient. “Why don’t we just set up insurance exchanges with, say, 12 different competing policies? We’ll let everybody choose a policy, and we’ll let people keep any money they save. That way they can set off a decentralised cascade of reform, instead of putting all the responsibility on us here”. And then Mr Hume would beg you to leave him alone.
I’ve introduced you to my friends Mr Bentham and Mr Hume because they represent the choices we face on issue after issue. This country is about to have a big debate on the role of government. The polarisers on cable TV think it’s going to be a debate between socialism and free-market purism. But it’s really going to be a debate about how to promote innovation.
The people on Mr Bentham’s side believe that government can get actively involved in organising innovation. (I’ve taken his proposals from the Waxman-Markey energy bill and the Baucus healthcare bill.)
The people on Mr Hume’s side believe government should actively tilt the playing field to promote social goods and set off decentralised networks of reform, but they don’t think government knows enough to intimately organise dynamic innovation.
So let’s have the debate. But before we do, let’s understand that Mr Bentham is going to win. The lobbyists love Bentham’s intricacies and his stacks of spending proposals, which they need in order to advance their agendas. If you want to pass anything through Congress, Bentham’s your man.
Maoists criminals, nobody’s saviours
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Hasina to discuss transit issue with India during visit
Dhaka: Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina is likely to visit India later this month when the politically contentious issue of giving transit facility to India through Bangladesh territory will be discussed, a newspaper said on Thursday.
Bangladesh Foreign Minister Dipu Moni's talks with the Indian leadership last month may have paved the ground for the visit of Sheikh Hasina, the New Age said. Dhaka agreed to allow New Delhi to use Bangladesh territory to carry goods to Tripura in northeast India during a meeting between Dipu Moni and her Indian counterpart S.M. Krishna in New Delhi September 8.
New Delhi has also long been pressing for a transit right through Bangladesh to carry goods to and from the northeast and has offered to invest in the development of necessary infrastructure. Indian authorities are yet to make any concrete financial offer regarding its investment in building the required infrastructure, unnamed sources in the Bangladesh foreign ministry told the newspaper.
The two countries are scheduled to sign a deal in May 2010 on India's access to the Ashuganj Port in Bangladesh that it wants to use to transport heavy equipment for a power plant in Tripura.
Former prime minister and opposition leader Khaleda Zia has already voiced her opposition to the move, resurrecting old fears that India could "exercise control" over Bangladesh's infrastructure facilities.
Foreign policy experts interviewed by the newspaper expressed diverse opinion on the issue that is being intensely debated politically. Many have suggested that Bangladesh should mobilise its own resources to invest in roads, railways and ports instead of allowing India to participate in their building.
Bangladesh will need an investment of $2.4 billion for building infrastructure to effectively join the Asian Highway network, including transit to India, which would link Bulgaria in Europe to Philippines in Southeast Asia, according to a study by the Asian Development Bank (ADB).
"We should thoroughly examine the requirements and modes of investments for a better regional connectivity. It is a question of our national interests, pride and dignity to develop our own infrastructures and I think we should afford the costs," former foreign secretary Shamsher Mobin Chowdhury said.
Imtiaz Ahmed, professor of international relations at Dhaka University, added that New Delhi realised that cooperation with Bangladesh was essential to develop the country, particularly its northeast region. "So, we should try to cash in on India's compulsion. We should think about long-term funding to establish regional connectivity, not merely India connectivity," he said.
Mostafa Faruk Mohammad, a former diplomat who is now a lawmaker and a member of the parliamentary standing committee on the foreign ministry, however, did not see any problem in receiving Indian funds.
"What is wrong if we take Indian investment as we are having investments from countries such as China and Japan in transport infrastructures?" he asked.
M. Rahmatullah, a former transport expert with the UN, pointed out that no concrete assurance of funding was in sight either from international financing institutions or private investors for developing road, rail and other connectivity.
"We need not invest money right now in establishing connectivity with India," he said.
A boy swims

A boy swims with his laundry through a flooded street at San Roque village, in Laguna province, 40 kms south of Manila, Philippines, on Thursday. A new typhoon gathered strength Thursday off the Philippines while nearly 700,000 people still sought help in badly stretched relief centers from massive flooding caused by Ketsana, one of the region's most destructive storms in years. — AP
Another quake strikes Indonesia, thousands feared dead
JAKARTA: Thousands of people were likely killed in a huge earthquake that struck Indonesia's Sumatra island, the Health Ministry's crisis centre head said on Thursday.
Rescue workers raced against time to assist victims of a huge earthquake on Indonesia's Sumatra island where upwards of 1,000 people are feared dead and many more trapped in rubble.
Another powerful quake struck Thursday south of the devastated area, but Indonesian authorities said there were no immediate reports of casualties from that quake, which they measured at 7.0 magnitude.
Wednesday afternoon's 7.6-magnitude earthquake caused buildings to crumble and fires to rage in Padang city, home to nearly a million people on the coast of Sumatra island, which was left largely without power and communications.
"The rescue personnel in the location estimated that so far at least 200 people have died," Disaster Management Agency spokesman Priyadi Kardono said in Jakarta.
But that number was likely to soar, officials said, as the first outside rescue teams from the Indonesian army and health ministry reached the city and surrounding towns to reinforce overwhelmed police on the ground.
Their task was to hunt for those still alive, in the twisted wreckage of collapsed hospitals, schools and homes.
"We need heavy machinery to lift the rubble... we expect that to arrive at the location soon," Kardono said.
At Padang's airport, parts of the roof had collapsed, leaving metal beams hanging down, an AFP correspondent said.
Health ministry crisis centre head Rustam Pakaya said a major city hospital was among the many buildings that had buckled.
"Houses and buildings have collapsed, causing thousands of people to be trapped inside in the rubble," Pakaya said.
He said he expected the death toll to soar over 1,000, given the scale of destruction and the large numbers of people feared buried in the rubble.
Yanto, a hotel receptionist in Padang, said electricity remained cut off on Thursday morning more than 15 hours after the quake.
"Our hotel has been heavily damaged. There are many cracks and rubble from fallen concrete," he said. "Thank God all our guests survived."
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, briefing reporters in Tokyo as he returned from the G20 summit in the United States, urged officials to "flood" the city with aid and medical relief.
Three military transport planes were preparing to deliver aid including tents, blankets and medicine, Disaster Management Agency spokesman Priyadi Kardono said.
"The effects of the earthquake could be as big as the Yogyakarta quake," he said, referring to a 2006 quake that killed 6,000.
British-based charity Oxfam said it had already earmarked 200,000 pounds (320,000 dollars) for relief efforts, including the distribution of emergency shelters, hygiene kits and clothing.
"We had aid ready because this area of Indonesia is susceptible to this type of tragedy," said Jane Cocking, the organisation's humanitarian director.
Panicked residents rushed from their homes and went fleeing through the streets after the quake struck off Sumatra's west coast at 5:16 pm (1016 GMT), 47 kilometres (29 miles) northwest of Padang.
It was felt in the Indonesian capital Jakarta, 940 kilometres (585 miles) away, and sent frightened office workers streaming out of buildings in nearby Singapore and the Malaysian capital Kuala Lumpur.
Dozens of aftershocks followed, including the major one Thursday which the US Geological Survey measured at 6.8 and said hit on land 225 kilometres (140 miles) southeast of Padang.
The Japan Meteorological Agency said there was a "very small possibility" of a destructive local tsunami in the Indian Ocean.
The Indonesian earthquakes followed a massive quake measuring 8.0 in magnitude that spawned a deadly tsunami in the Samoan islands of the South Pacific.
Like Indonesia, the islands sit on the volatile "Ring of Fire," a massive zone of volcanic instability that encircles the Pacific. Geologists said Padang, which lies near the colliding Indo-Australian and Eurasian tectonic plates, was vulnerable to more quakes and tsunamis.
"There are three big volcanoes in West Sumatra -- Merapi, Talang and Tandikat. We fear that this quake might cause volcanic eruptions there," said Geological Disaster Mitigation and Volcanology Centre head Surono.
Padang lies on the same tectonic faultline that cracked off Aceh, at the northern tip of Sumatra, in 2004 to trigger the Indian Ocean tsunami that killed more than 220,000 people.